The unit in brief

Lesson Description

Most people think plants are made from soil. Students test that idea with lettuce growing in an aquaponics raft with no soil at all. They weigh living plants for three weeks, repeat a famous 400-year-old experiment, and show that air has mass. Then they argue from evidence that plants are built mostly from air and water — not from the soil they are planted in.

Planning details

Lesson at a Glance

Grade level

5

Duration

5 weeks, 10 sessions, 50 minutes each (options for 60 or 75)

Format

5E (Engage, Explore, Explain, Elaborate, Evaluate)

NGSS standards

5-LS1-1, 5-PS1-1, 5-PS1-2, 5-PS3-1, 3-5-ETS1-1, 3-5-ETS1-2, 3-5-ETS1-3

Math

CCSS 5.NBT.B.7, 5.G.A.2

HĀ outcomes

All six: Belonging, Responsibility, Excellence, Aloha, Total Well-being, Hawaiʻi. Each session names an HĀ Focus.

System

Classroom aquaponics system with a float raft, plus three small soil pots and a 0.1 g scale

Hands-on activities

What Students Will Do

✓Design a method for weighing a living plant without harming it.

✓Weigh tagged raft lettuce seven times over 21 days.

✓Weigh soil before and after a plant grows in it.

✓Test whether air has mass with a ball and a fizzing bottle.

✓Dry lettuce to find out how much of it is water.

✓Build a model of photosynthesis and count the pieces.

✓Design a “Prove-It Station” to teach younger students.

Hawaiʻi connection

The Hawai‘i Connection

Kalo, ʻulu and koa are all built from island air and water, powered by island sun. Students ask what a koa canoe was made from before it was a tree, and look at how Wahiawā’s cool, humid climate changes the way plants use water.

10 sessions

Sessions

01

The Seed-to-Salad Mystery

02

How Do You Weigh a Living Plant?

03

Set Up Our Own Willow Test

04

Van Helmont’s Willow

05

Is Air Stuff?

06

Water In, Water Out

07

Building with Air

08

Design Challenge: The Prove-It Station

09

What Did the Mass Do?

10

Harvest and Built-from-Air Showcase

References

Sources

  • Michigan State University, Carbon TIME. Plants Unit (plant mass and common student ideas). carbontime.create4stem.msu.edu
  • “Jan van Helmont.” Encyclopedia.com (willow experiment).
  • USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, Release 28 (lettuce water content), as summarized by the Leafy Greens Marketing Agreement.
  • Ako, H. and Baker, A. (2009). Small-Scale Lettuce Production with Hydroponics or Aquaponics, SA-2. UH CTAHR.
  • UH CTAHR. Student and Food Safety: Best Practices for Hawaiʻi School Gardens, FST-45.
  • Hawaiʻi Department of Health. Rat lungworm prevention guidance.
  • NGSS Lead States (2013). Next Generation Science Standards: 5-LS1-1. nextgenscience.org
  • Hawaiʻi Board of Education Policy E-3, Nā Hopena Aʻo (HĀ). boe.hawaii.gov

Free for teachers

Before you download

Tell us who you are once and your downloads will start right away from then on in this browser. We would love to hear how the lesson went, so check the box if it is OK for us to follow up by email.

Lesson Plan Download